Here, with no advertising, and a current "last updated" date.

Red asterisks for the good ones, and see Le Parchemin (near McGill) for a massive takedown. I can attest to the accuracy of some of the reviews, at least last time I was in Montreal: Le Grand Comptoir is indeed "excellent, reasonably priced French cuisine." and Toqué was about taste, not just presentation, when it was on St. Denis.